Blaze Exclusive: First-Ever Music Video About the Holocaust Is a ‘Call to Arms’
- Posted on February 22, 2012 at 8:27am by Tiffany Gabbay
- Print »
- Email »
Last November, The Blaze reported on the production of the first-ever music video about the Holocaust. The song, entitled “Rainbow in the Night,” debuted January 27th to coincide with International Holocaust Remembrance Day.
“Rainbow in the Night” offers a powerful message in short form, specifically intended for a young post-millennial audience, as a reminder of the unspeakable cruelty inflicted on innocent men, women and children during the Holocaust. The video incorporates stunning cinematography, a heartrending score, and emotionally-wrought lyrics to produce a snapshot of the darkest time in the history of the Jewish people as seen through the eyes of a survivor.
The production, set against a backdrop of despair and hopelessness, reveals the emotional journey of an innocent child forced to leave his home for an extermination camp. After enduring the atrocities leveled against him by his captors, finally liberated, the child (now an adult in the video), recalls his journey. He also conveys the inspiration he felt upon reflecting on better days he hoped would come – all of which strengthened and sustained his resolve to survive.
Triumphantly culminating in the hope for a brighter future, ”Rainbow in the Night,” according to its producers, serves as a “euphoric tribute to the indomitable human spirit that enabled the Jewish people to survive against all odds,” as well as a “call to arms, to rekindle the spark of Jewish pride and unity among Jews worldwide as [they] continue to rebuild the generations that were destroyed by the Nazis.”
Filmed in New York, Krakow, and inside the Majdanek concentration camp, this first ever music video depicting the Holocaust was directed by Daniel, and includes a cast of approximately 60 men and women – both Jewish and non-Jewish – and over 800 Jewish children.
“This was not a set,” explained Cecelia and Daniel. “It was the real place.” These atrocities took place at Majdanek, and so the video captured the horrific and the emotional experience so vividly. Cecelia believes the haunting score, profound lyrics – performed by tenor Cantor Yaakov Lemmer – and visual imagery will convey the “tenacity” of the Jewish people who endured unthinkable tragedy and survived against all odds.
Cecelia ceded that while “we were decimated to a great extent,” as a people, “we survived.”
But like so many who share Jewish heritage, Daniel, too, was compelled to create this video for deeply personal reasons. For one, he is the grandson of Holocaust survivors and was profoundly inspired by the iconic film ”Schindler’s List.”
Yet Daniel brings with him the added element of being a survivor himself, as he and his family lived in Tzfat, Israel, during the second Lebanon War. For those unfamiliar, Tzfat was ground zero in 2006 — with some 4000 Katysusha rockets fired into northern Israel by Hezbollah, over 700 of them landed in Tzfat. Many civilians at the time time – especially those with large families and the elderly – were particularly vulnerable, lacking the ability to flee to safety.
Daniel recalled the devastation he witnessed as rockets and mortars fell directly into his own backyard.
Daniel, who is American-born, fortunately escaped through Jerusalem and returned to the U.S. so that he and his family could live in safety and security. He added that he is “in shock to this day,” having lived through conditions one only reads about in newspapers. For Daniel, the war was perhaps the greatest catalyst for making ”Rainbow in the Night,“ as he came to the haunting realization that his ”life as a Jew in [his] own country is not stable.”
He said the video is a message to those who would seek to destroy Israel and the Jewish people to: “Leave us alone.”
“You almost extinguished us. You killed us. What do you want from us? What do you want Iran? What do you want Arab world?”
Cecelia, whose own mother was a Holocaust survivor from Poland, found this labor of love a cathartic experience. According to the composer, her mother spoke faithfully at schools and throughout the community in order to educate others about the history of the Holocaust. Cecelia drew inspiration from her mother, who wrote about the experience of returning to Poland in order to find her father’s grave in the book “In Search of Ashes.”
When asked why they think the Holocaust denial and anti-Semitism is on the rise, both Cecelia and Daniel looked to Iran, citing how even the likes of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and his warped world-view is now entertained on a wide scale – even in the halls of academia.“You almost extinguished us. You killed us. What do you want from us? What do you want Iran? What do you want Arab world?”
Cecelia, whose own mother was a Holocaust survivor from Poland, found this labor of love a cathartic experience. According to the composer, her mother spoke faithfully at schools and throughout the community in order to educate others about the history of the Holocaust. Cecelia drew inspiration from her mother, who wrote about the experience of returning to Poland in order to find her father’s grave in the book “In Search of Ashes.”
As the conversation steered toward higher learning, Cecelia and Daniel also cited the abundance of anti-Israel sentiment by professors, activist groups and the BDS (boycott and divestment) campaign so prevalent on university campuses today. While many have come to expect such an environment in elite institutions like Columbia and Harvard, Cecelia ironically pointed out Brooklyn college – once a bedrock of a thriving Jewish community – where a professor was recently suspended, but later reinstated, after preaching anti-Semitism on a regular basis.
Another reason Daniel and Cecelia believe Holocaust denial and anti-Semitism is rising is because younger generations are less connected to their forebears than their predecessors were. Now, instead of having a close relative – a parent or grandparent – who survived the Holocaust, younger generations may only have a great-grandparent or distant relative affected by these events, if anyone at all. Thus, in their quest for assimilation, younger generations have abandoned their heritage.
“You want to remove yourself and not be burdened by this heavy past,” explained Cecilia. She reminded that even as Hitler rose to power, many Jewish people in Germany considered themselves German, rather than Jewish first.
Cecelia, who wrote the piece last year for a Holocaust commemoration, said that while at times wrought with emotion, she found the process of creating “Rainbow in the Night” “invigorating.”
“I feel good about what I did,” she beamed.
When asked about the obstacles they encountered abroad while working on a project of this magnitude, Daniel and Cecelia noted that bureaucracy in the Polish government held up their permit to operate at one point, but that eventually the production was given a green light.
Historically, while there were indeed Poles who were opposed to the extermination of Jews, there were many others who stood by cheering heartily as entire families were led away to ghettos and death camps by the Nazis. Sadly, it was not uncommon to see a group of Polish men, women and children all too happy to take over the apartments and personal effects these victims were forced to leave behind.“I feel good about what I did,” she beamed.
When asked about the obstacles they encountered abroad while working on a project of this magnitude, Daniel and Cecelia noted that bureaucracy in the Polish government held up their permit to operate at one point, but that eventually the production was given a green light.
In the spirit of accuracy, Daniel and Cecelia wished to capture such maddening moments from this snapshot in history. Some Polish cast members, however, took issue with their countrymen being portrayed in what they considered a negative light. This notion is quite apparent in the video.
While profoundly important, the subject matter is, of course, painful, and there were a number of moments throughout our conversation that caused the soul to swell with emotion – from the story of how a German nurse saved Cecelia‘s mother’s life in the concentration camp, to the chilling accounts of the second Lebanon War Daniel and his family barely survived as rockets and mortar shells peppered their home.
The most profound moment of the interview, perhaps, came when Cecelia and Daniel explained the “miracle” that happened in Poland, when, after a massive downpour following the conclusion of shooting, a huge rainbow appeared directly over the Majdanek concentration camp. Everyone present, from the cantor to the cast and crew, beheld this magnificent and, indeed, rarest of sights. According to Daniel and Cecelia, even those not Jewish became believers. Even more incredibly, the actual rainbow was captured and is featured below, courtesy of photographer, Agnieszka Traczewska.
The newly released, full-length “Rainbow in the Night” video follows. Its production scale is enormous. While most music videos are up and running in a matter of days or weeks, “Rainbow in the Night” took nearly half-a-year to finish, and includes a cast of hundreds filmed on two continents. Please watch the video below and share with others:
On a final note, due to their hostile climate, university campuses are among the first places Cecelia and Daniel hope to have “Rainbow in the Night” aired. The video is also slated to appear at Holocaust education institutions and centers across the country. In terms of the future, Daniel and Cecilia hope this video will travel as far as Iran. Interestingly, one of the places this video is also widely available is on Neo-Nazi websites, which may be a perfect indication why this video-message is so sorely needed.
For more information on the video and on how you can become involved, please visit: Rainbow in the Night
Merattor
Posted on February 24, 2012 at 7:06pm To all the liberal Jews…a prophecy,The next time they come for the Jews,
To torment them out of existence,
You will be as blind in the role of the suffering victim
As you are now in the role of enabling them.
There is a greater tragedy in your blindness
Than anything they could ever do.
For there are no anti-semites quite as dangerous
As rich American liberal Jews.
Report Post »
SGT Rock
Posted on February 24, 2012 at 10:27am Great video, all the smartypants people will not get it though. The longer one stays in college the dumber they become, politically speaking. I hope this work of art can truly shed Gods light on the ignorant that say the Holocaust is a lie, what fools. I’m not Jewish but I will not stand by and watch this happen again. As the Jewish people say, “Never Again”. As per the posts about the Jews being persecuted after WW3, I think that Isreal is ground zero and the Isrealies know it. May God cloak his people in safety and guide their actions as He sees fit. The rest of us are on the ride of our lives, pick a side and cowboy up.Report Post »
Natsdaughter
Posted on February 23, 2012 at 1:25pm Nice video but honestly, I’m kinda tired of seeing my fellow Jews being victimized. Perhaps the last few minutes of this video could have shown the importance of the 2nd Amendment and the need for Jews to arm ourselves. Shamefully, many of my fellow Jews are so lost in liberalism/socialism but there are still some of us who are not hostages to the left and who LOVE and CHERISH freedom. We somehow need to get the message out that Never Again means NEVER AGAIN!!!!Report Post »
deano24
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 11:08pm they did the same thing when they made the movie “The Boy in the Striped Pajamas” a sad story., plus they had Anne Frank.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hiding_Place_%28biography%29
Report Post »
flatbroke
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 5:57pm Very moving Vid, i welled up in the middle.The Jews have nothing to be ashamed of, and LHM on the folks who try to wipe them out. remember what happened to Germany after WW2, they got split in 1/2 between the west, and commies for 40 years, and the nazis were oblerated.Report Post »
bombshelterbob
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 3:03pm That was cool. It is a sin to not honor GOD’S Chosen people—and protect them.Report Post »
VicksVaporub
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 4:38pm When the Neocons get finished attacking Iran and causing WW3 everyone will blame Israel aka the Jews and the next Holocaust will begin and every religious Jew knows this.Report Post »
Lucy Larue
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 5:29pm @VICKSVAPORUB,You do realize what an ass you are. Non?
Why do you post in ignorance?! Why?!
You Vicks are like the DITTOS that teachers passed out back in the day. You are a sheep. You have nothing original to say. You embrace PROGRESSIVE groupthink.
It’s OKAY for you though Vicks. You’re EXACTLY the kind of person that our President Dunham banks on for his “FOUR MORE YEARS”.
Do you even know what a NEOCON is? I doubt it.
Again….,you’re an ass.
Report Post »
sweetnsalty
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 2:44pm I bet Soros would love this video, he would probably smile and say Oh this brings back such lovely memories,” as he said That was the best time of my life.”Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 6:39pm I imagine a lot of people would say the ages of 16-25 were the best days of their lives.. Esepcailly if they are over 70.Report Post »
SGT Rock
Posted on February 24, 2012 at 10:22am I agree with you, what monster could watch his people suffering and being butchered and say all he learned about it was to become a power mad egomaniac. Why does the world listen to this man or should I say beast, oops. Guess George is gonna put me on the naughty list.Report Post »
thegreatcarnac
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 2:21pm I stand with Israel but I am practical. When I see videos like that coming out and if we see more pro-Israeli material on the screens….then we know…war is coming again to the Middle east.Report Post »
midwesthippie
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:42pm …“blitzkrieg bop” by the ramones was probably the first…and yes my Jewish friends would laugh. incredible video…the story of the Jews is tremendous.Report Post »
abbygirl1994
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 12:43pm Beautiful.. I stand with Israel and the Jewish people! We must never let these atrocities happen again!Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:47pm Far more Germans and Russians died in WW2 then Jews. Are you not concerned for them?For the record how many Germans died? Russian? Oh you don’t know do you? hmmm That’s interesting. But you know how many supposedly died in this Holocaust? Even though the facts continually change?
The Jews have been milking the world long enough through their Holcocaust propaganda.. It’s time to get over it move on and stop perpetuating the lies.
How many Russians were hunted down and tried for War crimes? hmmm Interesting.
Report Post »
one.dakine.howlie
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 3:09pm TechEngineer you’re either a fool or purposely trying to deceive with your comments. Let‘s hope it’s the former.Between 1 and 3 million German citizens died in WWII. Another 5.5 million of their military servicemen died as well.
Between 12 and 14.5 million Soviet citizens died in WWII. Another 8-10 million of their military servicemen died.
Of the 9 million Jews in Germany, 2/3 were murdered leaving the death toll at around 6 million.
While you are correct in saying that Germany and the Soviet Union together had more casualties than the Jews there’s very little significance in that comparison. First of all many of the German and Soviet Union civilian casualties came from the fact that both their governments wouldn’t let citizens leave areas of hostility. They were forced to stay and fight alongside their respective military. Many of them only having mere farm tools to fight with. The Soviet Union was especially known for their brutal tactic of killing any citizen or military serviceman who tried retreating to safer locations.
Now lets look at the Jewish people of that time. They were rounded up by the very government who had vowed to protect them, locked up in cattle cars where many suffocated to death, then dumped off in camps to be slaughtered by the thousands each day. Men, women, and children given a death sentence for merely practicing their religion of choice. And that was just the few years of WWII. Try looking at their bloodier history be
Report Post »
josh345
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 11:24am @TECHENGINEER11: “Mr. Spielberg or Weinstien needs to make you a movie doesn’t he so that you may understand? Why won’t they make a movie detailing the horrors that took place in the former Soviet Union JP4JOY? Are they hiding something? Afraid? I‘m of the opinion that our Chosen really don’t want the microscope focused on what happened in 20th century Russia and I think I know why.”Are you really suggesting that Stalin was Jewish? Yes, Stalin had Jewish ancestry, but he was definitely not Jewish. Many Jews suffered under Soviet Russia. Also, Stalin re-established the Moscow Patriarchate. Stalin also was enraged when his oldest son, who was Jewish, wanted to marry a Jew, and caused his son to shoot himself. Stalin was definitely NOT Jewish. Perhaps a reason why Spielberg hasn‘t made movies about Stalin is because Spielberg isn’t Russian. Spielberg has a connection to the Jews, so he makes movies about them, while Russian filmmakers can make movies about Russians.
Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 6:41pm Tried several times to respond but the moderator obviously didn’t like my post..Report Post »
marthasusan40
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:23am This is beautiful…Report Post »
The_Jerk
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:06am Norman Finkelstein was spot on with his, “The Holocaust Industry: Reflections on the Exploitation of Jewish Suffering.”Since WWII, the world, more specifically the western world, has been awash in a never ending and quite complex media barrage, by Jews, in regards to the holocaust. Museums, films, videos, articles, books… all with the specific purpose to exploit the memory of the Nazi Holocaust for political and financial gain, as well as to further the interests of Israel. This ethnic centered, ethnic specific, wedge, becomes all the more disgusting when one realizes that over 40 million people suffered and died.
I see no end to this ethnic specific propaganda, since Jews admittedly have an asymmetric influence on what the western culture perceives as reality: http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/commentary/la-oe-stein19-2008dec19,0,4676183.column
Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:24am Jerk: Thanks for your uncompromising and persistent service to our country. You are a true Patriot in the purest sense. We must fight their lies and propaganda on all fronts or before you know it American’s will be thrown in Jail like Europeans for simply questioning their Holocaust industry.Look I use to hate people that would tell me the truth or tell me things that went against the way I had been taught or programmed. It’s hard to confront the truth sometimes. We just have to keep pushing out the facts.
On another note you post a lot. It appears that you are not censored. I bet only 30-40% of my post ever see the light of day.
Report Post »
jcizarter
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:33am My Jewish relatives will never forget, you may want them to, but they won’t.Report Post »
welloddyfriggindah
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:43am Wow. I recognize and respect your right to speak your mind. I don’t pretend to know what is in your heart, or the hearts of those who are moved to produce a piece to make their thoughts or feelings known. Especially not whole groups, religions, ethnicities.Report Post »
The_Jerk
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:53am No one has been censored, or unjustly punished, more than Norman Finkelstein. He found out firsthand that the truth can have very few friends and a whole lot of enemies. He’s a patriot and a man that we should all admire. He speaks truth to the powerful and he has the wounds to prove it.Juxtapose Finkelstein to the propagandist Alan Dershowitz, who for years has hid behind Harvard. Both are intellectually astute men. Both are well educated. Both are well written. Both are well traveled. Both are professors. One is ostracized by an academic society that should invite debate and entertain all points of view. The other elevated and honored for defending the conventional wisdom from truth.
I always feel sad when I think of Norman Finkelstein, a great man treated with such contempt.
Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:05pm @JerkMaybe you should also condemn the violence against David Horowitz then. He often needs a security detail just to be able to speak freely at most colleges. Even then he is frequently interrupted and not permitted to speak plainly.
Report Post »
the wireworker
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 4:17pm norman finkelstein is a self hating jew and a self described communist but don’t hold that against him he only supports hamas and hezbollahReport Post »
JQCitizen
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:54am Very beautifully, and tastefully done video, and the music is lovely, too! So tastefully done that I can use it in conjuction with some good books to introduce my young grandchildren to the concept of the idea of people being persecuted and discriminated against.Report Post »
MOLLYPITCHER
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:19am @JQCITIZENThats a good idea. I think I’ll use this for my kids. Such a horrible time in history that is sometimes very hard to read about, but we have to remember it and we have to teach it so that it is not forgotten. I often find in reading, that there was some atrocity that I hadn’t thought of. Those things are so awful that my mind doesn’t go there. I believe that it is so important for to tell children about this, while sparing them many of the details. This video is a good thing to start with.
Report Post »
rose-ellen
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 11:09am that the european holocaust is now used to support zionist land grabs and occupation of arab palestinians and a racist state is the current crime happening vis a vis the european jews.i stand with the displaced and occupied arab palestinians-israel should go legal and return to the 67borders .Gulls!Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:10pm RoseWhy did the Zionist movement begin? The Holocaust is just one case in hundreds of years of Jewish persecution. And once again, there is no such thing as a “67 border”. Borders are boundaries agreed upon by sovereign states and recognized by both sides. The Arabs you support have never recognized the “67 borders”. After 1967, the Arabs declared that they wouldn’t recognize Israel or make peace with her. The 1948 armistice line was nonbinding.
Report Post »
FoxholeAtheist
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:40am Quit baptizing dead jews into the mormon church!Report Post »
MOLLYPITCHER
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:21am I’m not a Mormon, but I do know that you can’t baptize someone who is already dead. What do you think they’re doing? Taking the dead bodies and dunking them? Give me a break, and stop trolling.Report Post »
marvel
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 11:04am Though he is attempting to mock our religion, FoxholeAtheist is talking about our practice of vicarious baptism. It is the main reason we do family history work. We seek out the names of our kindred dead and are baptized on their behalf in our temples. We do this because we believe that the spirits of the dead continue to live after departing this life, and that missionary work continues in the spirit world. Because they no longer have their bodies, then cannot be baptized unless one of us (who are yet alive) stands as proxy on their behalf, should they accept the gospel message. Since we do not know who has and who has not accepted the gospel in the spirit world, we try to do the work for everyone. It does not mean that we consider them “Mormons” automatically. It means that should they choose it, the baptism would become effective, as if they had done it themselves while still in mortality. (see 1 Peter 3:18-22, and 1 Cor. 15:29)Report Post »
MOLLYPITCHER
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 11:50am @MARVELI did not know that. So I learned something about Mormonism today. Thank you for letting me know.
Report Post »
marvel
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 2:37pm @MOLLYPITCHERMy pleasure. This subject has been particularly controversial when it comes to Jewish Holocaust victims. Over the years, some latter-day saints motivated by compassion towards holocaust victims have specifically sought out their names and performed those vicarious baptisms on their behalf. This practice being a “labor of love” from our perspective – giving folks an opportunity to be baptized after the opportunity to do it themselves was taken away when they were murdered. However, many in the Jewish community viewed our practice as offensive, and latter-day saints have been asked to stop doing those ordinances without permission of nearest living survivors. Though, I think when it is understood that we do not believe that the ordinances are effective unless those deceased spirits choose to accept them, that it really shouldn’t be offensive.
This doctrine answers the question, “If baptism is necessary, as Jesus and the Apostles taught, what about those who die without ever having a chance to accept the gospel or be baptized?”. The answer, according to Mormonism, as that there is still an opportunity before the resurrection for those individuals to learn about and accept the gospel, and have their baptisms performed on their behalf by us who are still alive.
Report Post »
JP4JOY
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:39am IMHO there is no music or modern video that can accurately portray the horror and depravity of genocide. God’s chosen people have been the ones man has persecuted throughout history. Of course there are others, Cambodians (half of the population), chinese dissidents,Stalin’s enemies, the Kurds in Iraq etc. These events are perpetrated by insane leaders who scare their populations into becoming complicit lest they too are persecuted. Standing up against EVIL is harder than most people can imagine. Most of us go along to get along until it’s too late. It’s the human condition.Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:18am JP4JOYPosted on February 22, 2012 at 9:39am
IMHO there is no music or modern video that can accurately portray the horror and depravity of genocide. God’s chosen people have been the ones man has persecuted throughout history
I thought Mao killed up to 80 million Chinese? We have the Holodomor where 8-10 million Christians were starved to death during a time of peace by the Jewish Marxist in Moscow. You’re asertion is simply not true. It appears that God’s unchosen have been far more abused and usually by his Chosen.
Mr. Spielberg or Weinstien needs to make you a movie doesn’t he so that you may understand? Why won’t they make a movie detailing the horrors that took place in the former Soviet Union JP4JOY? Are they hiding something? Afraid? I‘m of the opinion that our Chosen really don’t want the microscope focused on what happened in 20th century Russia and I think I know why.
Report Post »
marvel
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 11:32am @techengineer11Joseph Stalin was from a Georgian Orthodox background, not a Jew, and was responsible for killing millions of his own people including Jews.
Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 11:46am marvelPosted on February 22, 2012 at 11:32am
@techengineer11
Joseph Stalin was from a Georgian Orthodox background, not a Jew, and was responsible for killing millions of his own people including Jews.
What Stalin was is debatable. I know that the mainstream Media wants to label him Orthodox because it fits their agenda. He may have been but I doubt it. Regardelss the upper echelon of Soviet power from 1917-1953 was almost 100% Jewish Stalin withstanding. Yes Stalin killed Jews toward the end of his life. Would one suggest that person of a particluar ethnicity couldn’t kill the very same people? I hear that a lot. Very strange logic.
It was the NKVD that carried out most of the atrocities in Russia including both the Katyn Massacre and the Holodomor and we all know how Jews flock to security agencies just like they have in America. For example consider:
Carl Levin: Head of Senate Armed Services Committee. Coauthor and sponsor of the NDAA 1687 civilian detainment law just recently passed.
Michael Chertoff: United States Secretary of Homeland Security co-author of the USA PATRIOT Act and founder of the Chertoff Group which represents manufacturers of the H.S. scanners.
Joe Liberman: Chairman of the Senate Homeland Security Committee.
Diane Fienstien: Head of Senate Intelligence committee.
Daniel Benjiman: Head of Counter Terrorism.
Leon Panetta: Sec of Defense.
Debbie Wasserman Schultz: Head of DNC
Research it.
Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:25pm @TechYour comments make it clear that you don’t believe that Jews should be allowed to hold any position of authority. Joe Lieberman is an elected Senator. Are you saying Jews shouldn’t be allowed to run?
And as for Russia, every oppressed group was represented in the uprising. Prior to the Bolsheviks there existed a privileged class in Russia. The Bolshevik revolution, like the French, Chinese, Egyptian etc., instead of bringing about a change in societal structure, simply brought about a change in who was in charge. There were Jews who supported the French Revolution and Napoleon because French Jews were emancipated for the first time. A small handful of Jews being Bolsheviks is comparable to only some Germans being Nazis. I, as a Jew, don’t blame Germans for the Holocaust yet you blame all Jews for the actions of Jewish Bolsheviks. That’s collectivism Tech. You know the kind you claim to hate. You bias and hypocrisy are without bounds it would seem.
Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:38pm tzion: Oh my point is rather simple and that is Marxism a creation of the Jew Karl Marx is overwhelmingly a Jewish phenomenon and it is without question the biggest evil on earth.Do I need say anymore? Unfortunately most Americans do not understand this. If I can help others see it then I’m doing a worthwhile deed.
As far as a your small percentage drivel again while Jews made up 2-3% of the Russian population something like 300 of 350 Commissars in the former Soviet state were Jewish. Do you dispute this fact or will you acknowledge it?
Do we have to start naming names? They are recorded you know.
Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 2:01pm @TechYes you should name names. List the individuals responsible. There are MILLIONS of Jews in the world and yet you condemn them all for the actions of a few HUNDRED. The reason Jews are overrepresented is because, even as low class citizens, Jews still valued education. How many non-Jewish Russians peasants were educated? Jews are predominately literate in almost every society they were a part of. That’s why they knew about Marx. They held many positions because there were few who could compete. And even 300 is small compared to how many Jews lived in Russia. Name the 300 and condemn them. You don’t see me condemning Germans.
Report Post »
marvel
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 2:41pm Tech is just proving that Joseph Goebbels Nazi propaganda was quite effective in blinding the eyes of the people, and in justifying (in their own minds) their diabolical behavior, even today.Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 2:46pm You know Tech, I would estimate that 95-100% of Nazis were German. All Germans must therefore be evil Nazis, right?Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 3:18pm marvel:Goebels had a PhD. Why do you disgregard everything he said? The Germans were probably the most educated people on the earth in the 30s.. Do you think there were just entirely deceived by propaganda? Do you really think that?Do you believe every assertion the man made was false? How can you be so ridiculous? Take the assertions he made or anyone at that time and let’s analyze them.
lol
I bet if Beck says something it‘s the Gospel truth isn’t it? Even though he doesn’t even have a HS education does he? Certainly no college.
Report Post »
marvel
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 4:08pm @techengineer11A degree in higher education does not necessarily make his propaganda correct, or even true. But, actually, no I don’t think that every assertion Goebbels made was false. Some things he said seemed alright. At least on one occasion, for example, Goebbels made a decent case against morality being enforced by government, if a people were to enjoy life (see “More Morality, Less Moralism”, 1934).
His assertions about Communism, and the Bolsheviks, on the other hand were false, and were designed to maintain antisemitism as the prime struggle of Germanic people. Regardless of the fact that it is dangerous to human freedom in it’s own right, Goebbels was successful in convincing the masses that Jews were behind Marxism – that it was the means by which Jews conspired to rule the world and destroy modern civilization (see “Communism with the Mask Off”, 1935). No wonder a whole people felt justified in their lethal persecution of the Jews, many who were their own countrymen, and were not involved in any “conspiracy”. He mixed common sense and some truth, with just enough lies to further the Nazi agenda. He was a master at propaganda, not truth or honesty.
Report Post »
marvel
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 4:25pm @techengineer11And I don’t know what Beck has to do with this. I accept all truth, no matter what the source. However, it is simply not true that Jews by virtue of “their birth and their race” are part of an international conspiracy” against the Germanic people, as Goebbels often taught. However, it is most likely true that all Jews conspire against National Socialism, and like ideologies. But who would blame them at this point. I am also proudly against any ideology that calls for my destruction.
Report Post »
techengineer11
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 6:58pm marvel: “His assertions about Communism, and the Bolsheviks, on the other hand were false, and were designed to maintain antisemitism as the prime struggle of Germanic people…. Goebbels was successful in convincing the masses that Jews were behind Marxism – that it was the means by which Jews conspired to rule the world and destroy modern civilization (see “Communism with the Mask Off”, 1935).”Well I have to agree with Goebbels on this point. I can’t deny the facts before my face. Before I was aware of the facts there was no greater supporter of Israel than the Jews than I. I had literally given thousands of dollars to the Nation of Israel through the Hagee ministry. I’ve studied these assertions in detail for the past 5-6 years and I can’t deny the strong correlations between Marxism and Jews and I was extremely biased against the supposition.
My goodness I wish I could. I wish it wasn’t so. If you would read “Behind Communism” by Frank Britton and point out the falsifications in it. Not only were they behind Bolshevism in Russia they were behind it in Germany. My god it was a movement of Jews that tried to overthrow Germany after WW1. They were the ones behind the Frankfurt School.
So you are saying unequivocal that you do not see a strong correlation between Marxism and Jews? I think it’s as highly correlated as Blacks and the Democrat Party. Do you deny that correlation as well?
Report Post »
marvel
Posted on February 23, 2012 at 12:44am @techengineer11Blacks and the Democratic party? Are you kidding me? All they are are pawns in the Democratic party. The same white supremacy reigns in the Democratic party today as it did when the first Republican President took office. They have just figured out a way to keep blacks down and in slavery, while appearing to help them, simultaneously exploiting them for political purposes.
Allen West was right when he called the Democratic party a modern-day “plantation”.
Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 23, 2012 at 1:13am @TechCorrelation means very little. Maybe instead of saying “Jews are all Marxists” you should ask yourself why there are so many Marxist Jews. After all, I could point out how many antisemites were Christian but that wouldn’t be reason enough to hate Christians. The truth is that in Europe, unlike America, rights came from government and were not inherent to every person. The rulers and the upper classes would rule over the lower classes. Marxism was the first ideology to offer a way out for many of these people, only it still was built within a totalitarian system. Only in America was constitutional republicanism ever successful. Meanwhile, some Jews, who had been persecuted for being different for centuries, began to try and become more like everyone else. Only they were still treated as different in many cases. Hitler is a prime example: he didn’t discriminate between religious and secular Jews. This was particularly true in Russia and Eastern Europe (which is also where socialism took hold interestingly enough). These new secular Jews came to see those with money and power as the enemies. Since Jews are historically well educated, they came across the writings of Marx and were seduced by his ideas which they then spread. Since Jews are one of the few groups of low or middle class status to receive education, they naturally took center stage. But even then, it was still a minority of Jews involved.
Report Post »
shogun459
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:28am “…due to their hostile climate, university campuses are among the first places Cecelia and Daniel hope to have “Rainbow in the Night” aired.”What about our University’s and Campuses makes them “hostile” to survivors of the Holocaust?
Could it be that the Professors and Staff of Universities are preaching anti-semitism?
Could it be that the supposed bastions of acceptance and tolerance are in fact a hotbed of intolerance for anything NOT Socialist?
Report Post »
constitutionaldirective
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:18am Darn I thinking Ronnie James Dio… :(Report Post »
acovenantinblood
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:28am Me too! Miss that guy.Report Post »
DD313
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:10am I Remember Mad magazine alluding to something like this in their 1960′s parody of “Hogan’s Heroes.”Report Post »
shogun459
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:29am I have been to Dachau, it’s not funny.Report Post »
shogun459
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 9:29am I have been to Dachau it’s not funny.Report Post »
DD313
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:08am I have been to Dachau, too. If you saw the (Jewish edited) Mad magazine parody, it was making the very point that World War II was anything but funny, and that was fifty years ago. This video was quite powerful, by the way.Report Post »
The_Jerk
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 10:11am I’ve been there too, and it’s far past the time to stop with this ethnic specific propaganda. Millions of people suffered and lost loved ones. Seventy percent of the casualties during WWII were civilians.Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:28pm @JerkThe history of the Holocaust is ethic based propaganda. To properly study the Holocaust is to understand that fact. The whole “Aryans first” and “Jews are evil” and all the other propaganda from that era are tied up with the very source of the Holocaust. To ignore that is to invite a repeat of history.
Report Post »
tzion
Posted on February 22, 2012 at 1:32pm I’ve been to Auschwitz, Krakow, Warsaw, Majdanik, and numerous other places. There are things there even I didn’t know to expect. Did you know that at Majdanik there’s a bathtub INSIDE the crematorium because someone decided that the heat from the burning corpses was being wasted? So he used it for his bath water.Report Post »